Already a Member?
Become a Member
 
Music Articles
In This Issue
This week, a look at categories by gender.
Kick off the new year with this fresh singer-songwriter.
A surprisingly unexciting way to start off 2009.
A couple Kids, a "French" band and more!
 
Music Articles
In This Issue » Music » Kelly Clarkson

Kelly Clarkson

My December

Written by: Josh M., Senior Editor – Posted: Thu Jun 28th, 2007
Tools
Kelly Clarkson
My December


I've been saying it for years: If I want pop give me pop, meaning that the last thing I want is the "deep thoughts" of an uber-successful pop-star writing about a "stupid-jerk" of an ex-boyfriend/girlfriend or that the media doesn't understand their "complex character traits" (the same theory applies for all forms of entertainment). The cold hard truth is that pop-stars these days come a dime-a-dozen, with a large percentage of them maintaining a career based on one facet of talent, be it a great voice or...uh...being palatable - nothing more, nothing less.

By all accounts, "Since U Been Gone" was a great song that has proven to stand the test of time. The chiming guitars paired with Kelly Clarkson's stammering vocals hit the spot for many a popular music listener, including myself. But did she own that song? Was it as a symbolic departure of her squeaky-clean American Idol roots? No, and no. It's a great song that Clarkson was smart enough to sing - nothing more, nothing less.

The closest record in overall feel to My December is Pink's genre-defiant M!ssundaztood. Where Pink was spilling her guts over AOR rockers Clarkson one-ups the spunky-punkster with a fistful of nu-garage ("Hole"), starry-eyed R&B ("Yeah") and a brooding acoustic gem that's sure to beefen-up her somewhat-ironic indie credibility ("Irving"). Still, you can audibly hear the strain of Clarkson trying to impress throughout most of My December, "Sober" being a major culprit of consciously looking over one's shoulder for acceptance.
Post Your Comment
To leave a comment, click here to login or sign up
  
View Comments
this cd has alot of inspiration toward the kids who love singing
. At frist i was like this is not goinig to be a great cd but
when i got ure cd it was so thrilling and i loved every mintue of
her cd !!!!!!!! i hope she puts out more of her fntastic music
good luck kelly !!!!!
i just got her cd today and i love tht her songs rnt just "pop".
they actually have meaning. i love Kelly and im sad her tour got
cancelled :(
Can't wait to get her new album... I know it's gonna rock, no
matter what critics say!
I am a big fan of Kelly's and have been since her days on American
Idol, so I'm glad that she's out with new music. I hate how
marginalized everyone has made her, by refusing to support
anything that different from her last album "Break Away". I think
Kelly can sing the hell outta any genre.
I love Kelly and I love this CD. I'm a lyrics person, and what I
like about this one is that I can totally relate to most of the
songs. I loved "Maybe" when she sang it on tour and I'm so happy
it made this album. "Irvine" is amazing.

She really risked losing a lot of fans with this album, but I'm
glad she is doing what SHE wants.
weird..i just noticed this..kelly clarksons..fingers are kinda
puggy like mine..thats rare usually there not that way..hmm..yes
i'm weird i notice these things..well she uses her hand alot in
this video..
Not to be snotty.. but just because an artist tries something new
doesn't mean she's trying too hard. And just because she's a pop
singer doesn't make her stupid, either.

I will say I have only heard one song "Never Again" which does
sort of sound like she's straining. But it is kind of catchy.. and
as much as I loved her last CD, I'm anxious to hear more from this
one.
I agree that her motives for moving in a different direction are
fine as pie; I'm just saying that she doesn't have the songwriting
talents to keep her vision afloat. Who knows - maybe I'll be
eating my own words this time next album.

As for "stood the test of time": I unfortunately agree and that's
my point: With "hit songs" being churned out every nanosecond
you'd be stunned to remember one hit song in 2007 two years from
now. It's just sad that "standing the test of time" these days is
literally one calendar year from the release date of a
single/album.

Without falling into nostalgia try to name 25 immortal songs from
the 90's, both commercially and creatively successful. I'm not
saying YOU can't name them - I'm just saying it's tougher than it
would be, oh, twenty years ago. We live in a diluted market where
everybody's brother and sister are in a band...much more muck to
wade through, if by density alone.
I like the album, there are a few songs I don't like, and some of
the titles are stupid, but I'm glad Kelly stuck to her guns and
did what she wanted. I support her 100%. Go Kelly!
Im not fond of Sober, and Never Again was okay the first few
times, but now it just irks me.

Because of You was always my favorite by her.
I absolutely LOVE Kelly. She's really grown as an artist. I love
her entire album. It's got a rock-raw edge to it but who cares,
it's a great album, one you can listen to without skipping any
songs. Her previous album was that way too. Most artists can't
do that.

Keep it up Kelly!!!
I don't believe Kelly is trying to "prove" that she can be
serious. She wanted to go more in the direction of what she likes
and what she wants to become as an artist, and more credit to her
for standing up for herself and taking her career by the reins and
steering it where she wants it to go.

And "Since U Been Gone" has not stood the test of time. It's been
out for what, maybe 2 years now? That's not the test of time,
haha. When its still getting airtime in 15 years, THEN you can
say that.
I just got the cd today and it is awesome. It is more rock and
raw, but it's very good. She has grown has an artist, I think. I
absolutely love the song "Maybe" It's a beautiful song.
I absolutely LOVE the track "Maybe." I'm surprised it isn't
getting more attention! It's beautifully written and beautifully
sang.
Can't wait to buy the CD. Never Again rocks!!!
some people say this cd is not that good compared to previous,
probably cuz its more about breakup stuff when kelly clarkson said
she never was in love before, dunno thats what critics used.
ZOMG..listen to one song..."never again" this isn't pop this is
real..she does sing this song with lots of emotion..the lyrics are
genus...you know you can tell when some one actually writes a song
then sings it they use words like "sucks"...and describe the
situation..like it actually happened....i've know two songs that
have the word "sucks" and the other song was written by avril
lavinge she was writeing her own songs..so..yeah..
I loved the song Never Again. I'm gonna buy this CD no matter the
review.
i can't wait to go buy it. i don't care what reviews say. i've
bought every one of kelly's other cds and i loved them!
Haven't really taken it out of my CD player since I got it.
This new CD is incredible. Good for Kelly for breaking through the
restraints of a typical pop star and proving she is so much more.
Not only did she cowrite every single song on the album, you can
hear the emotion echoing through her heartfelt lyrics. Kelly
cannot be compared to Pink. Pink has always been edgy and
dissatisfied and kind of annoying. Kelly is just using her music
as an emotional outlet. You should be congratulating her.
haven't heard the album yet, but from the interviews i've read of
kelly promoting this album, i sooooo agree with this article!!!!
she is definitely one of those pop artists trying to be "deep" and
i hate that! i just want to tell her that it's OKAY to be a
teenybopper pop star, it's OKAY to have fun, catchy tunes, it's
OKAY to sing songs written by other people !!!!

I'm so sick of pop stars trying to "write" songs (mandy moore,
hilary duff, etc) b/c all the losers during the teen pop/boyband
era criticized pop music for not "writing their own music" and not
"singing what they feel." who friggin cares........ whitney
houston never wrote her own songs but her voice, in addition to a
well-written pop song, made her greatest hits memorable. this is
the same reason why "since u been gone" was such a hit--- kelly's
voice and max martin's writing! i love kelly clarkson, but i feel
that most of her songs on her cds are filler, and most of the ones
that i consider filler are the ones she wrote herself! despite my
huge rant, i'll still check out her cd anyway b/c i love her
voice!
I've listened to this CD about 12 times now and have yet geto
figure out how I feel about it.