Already a Member?
Become a Member
 
Entertainment Articles
In This Issue
"All About What Lies Beneath"
"The Secret Wedding of the American Teenager"
Looking back with a guilty smile!
"The L Word"
When you can expect your favorite shows to return
Blake Lively, Leighton Meester, Chace Crawford, Ed Westwick
Who will win, who should win?
Who should win, who will win?
They keep us watching!
January 3rd you better tune in!
She's on our watch list for 2009!
Little Daggers album and his time on Ugly Betty!
 
Entertainment Articles
In This Issue » Entertainment » Whitney's Top Model Win

Whitney's Top Model Win

The first plus-size victory.

Written by: Kristen Dunleavy, Senior Editor – Posted: Tue May 20th, 2008
Tools
Like most competition-oriented reality shows, each season of America's Next Top Model contains a few token contestants that realistically have a very slim chance of winning. The sad thing about this show is that plus-sized models were never seen as actual contenders for the title- until now.

This past week, Whitney Thompson of Atlantic Beach, Florida became the first ever plus-size model to win on ANTM. At 5'10 and a size 10, she's hardly a sample size. Regular models are typically a size 4 at most, though the majority is in the size 2 range. When Whitney auditioned for the show in Orlando, she saw the other girls freaking out over weight issues. Rather than getting all self-conscious, she radiated confidence and told reporters afterwards, "My body rocks!"

Throughout the show, Whitney kept that same positive attitude, but still received harsh criticism from other contestants and judges alike. One of the judges, Paulina Porizkova, never seemed to give poor Whitney a break. At one point she called her a 'ham' and said she didn't think Whitney wasn't taking the show seriously. All of the judges at one point or another agreed she was 'fake' or 'too pageant.'
Post Your Comment
To leave a comment, click here to login or sign up
  
View Comments
i thought that this was good this time but it surprised me that
the big gurl won but i liked her, so i think it is good for her to
win, she was not really what you would call big
I didn't see ANTM.I saw some of the shows,but I am glad they pick
someone that is not a stick girl.It is something new to hear about
because it is the first time on the show to ever have someone that
is out of the toothpick stick pack (if you know what I mean).You
really don't have to be a size 0 to be a hot girl because what you
are doing is hurting yourself.I don't really like any of the
judges because they are rude.They don't see that when they get old
they will be fat and ugly.They talk so much about girls and women
that are plus size but they don't see that is not what guys think
about them. Guys now, don't want to have a girl that is so skinny
she does not have any breast or don't have any meat either.They
want girls they can grab a hold of and feel too.
The world today is saying that being thin is in, but that is not
the truth.You can exercise and still look and feel great and not
go overboard.You don't need to kill yourself to be a model.Life is
too short to think of things like that.Its not worth it.Girls like
that are lucky to be a model or actress.They should count their
blessings because people like me or someone else that is poor with
no money they want to have a dream job like that.People have to
see the background of being a model because I found out that the
people that take pictures of them tells the girls to lose weight
than they are suppose to.They will be a size 8 and want them to be
a size 4 in 2 months!!!! That is crazy!!Some girls are really
snobs and don't really care what happens to them and you know
what, their time will be up.They are just showing something that
is not real.They are all fake because they are not showing who
they really are.When people find out they will change their mind
about them.But the show is something I will not tell someone
because you will become obsess about being a model.Then you will
think that you will have a model body.After that you will become
crazy about everything you eat and see.So take this from me,MODELS
ARE FAKE!!!
plus size in the modeling industry is anything over a size 6.

Im considered plus sized and I get yelled at from people for being
"too skinny".
i wear a size 26, so to hear that size 10 or 12 is considered
"fat" and "plus size" makes me want to puke
AH!
I missed the last few episodes AND the finale because of finals at
school!
MAN!
I'm so glad she won!
She was one of my favorites. Her and Anya.
I'm SO buying her issue.
whoo whoo.
I was so excited to hear that Whitney won!! As I watched the
beginning episodes I couldn't beleive she was even called a "plus
size" shes so gorgeous and slim

Would Tyra be considered a plus size? Shes definitly not a two!
Interesting.....my mom wears a size ten and looks thin as a rail.

Plus sized is not size ten...or twelve....

By the by, Marilyn Monroe was a size 12.....and no one called her
anything but beautiful.



I don't see why it's such a big deal that you don't think that
she's plus-sized or that she didn't deserve to win.

I'm almost exactly her same size and height - just a couple inches
shorter, and I'm teetering between size 8 and 10.

Admittedly, there was one cycle (I want to say 7 or 8, but I'm
probably wrong as usual since there are now ten to keep up with)
with a girl who was definitely plus-sized that I was rooting for,
and when she was cut, I was pretty upset; I never got to watch
this cycle, but the fact that my friends in my classes were all
talking about her and saying "I want the plus-sized model to win"
meant something: that it doesn't matter if a 10 in your town isn't
plus-sized; it's that a girl who stood out among the 0-2-4-sized
girls and beat them all - something I wish I could do, but
probably can't.

So if you really have a problem with this, then...what is it? You
say that she didn't deserve to win, but that happens everywhere
every day - it's called life. You'll come across things like this
everywhere, but, for the moment, I think that Whitney's an
excellent example that girls who aren't single-digits can still
become *something*, no matter if it's a plus-sized model or
something else; she should be looked at as a role model, not just
a girl who "is supposed to be fat/large but isn't really and
shouldn't be called plus size and shouldn't have won".
was pretty horrible
especially in that gorgeous versace gown but im really am glaad
she won...but still her walk!
in the modeling world, whitney is consider as "plus" size. but
still, this cycle just made me want to watch it less espeically
cycle 8 &9 were so bad, i wished the top 4 who were in this cycle
could have won cycle 8 and 9, like fatima-has a really good reason
to role model for girls, anya-fit the high-fashion model category.
but cycle's 10 winner, whitney? hello the show was rigged, i bet
she's gonna go back to her size 2 in few weeks.
since when does being a size 10 make you a plus sized girl? that's
ridiculous!! the size 10's and 12's aren't even in a plus side
section of a store!! i'm a size 12 and hardly look like a plus
sized girl. it's nice to see a healthier looking person win a
modeling show but the whole show in general is just stupid
anyways. THE GIRL IS NOT PLUS SIZED!!!! STOP CALLING HER
THAT!!!!!!
She doesnt deserve it. She was skinny. The casting people told her
to gain weight for the show to be "plus sized".
I personally think Anya deserved to win. But hey, I am pleased
that a plus-sized girl has won ANTM at last.
I'm glad that a plus sized model won, but to be honest I really
thought that Anya was the more talented model.
no. no no no. first of all, this girl is not a model. not because
she's big, but because she is not that pretty (in my opinion) and
takes terrible pictures (close your mouth!). watching this season
was so awful, because you could just tell it was rigged for a plus
size girl to win. there were much MUCH better contestants this
season that were 1000x better models than whitney. it is
absolutely bogus that whitney won over anya, because anya took
some really awesome pictures throughout the whole thing.
what bugs me the most is that whitney had a bad attitude, and
would constantly put down the skinny girls she was competing with
to make herself feel better. making comments like "ohhh i'm here
to represent girls that actually eat well!" uhh yeah.. some people
are naturally skinny, and eat just fine! she made comments every
episode like that.
and technically she's not a plus-size model because they're
usually sizes 12-14.. so that would put whitney in the middle.
that's what fatima was trying to say.

hah.. those are just some of the problems i have with this cycle
in general. but whatever, tyra is whack.
I think it's absolutely fabulous that a "plus sized" model won
ANTM finally. Previous seasons they all seemed rather whiney, but
Whitney wasn't which was quite nice. I just didn't like how Tyra
is saying that Whitney is a "full figured" model...as opposed to
what, a "half figured" model? It's about time we had a model who
wasn't a size 0...so congrats to her!
Tschuess, tootles, und liebe.
Re